Osborne's Plan for Pension Poverty

George Osborne is in danger of single-handedly destroying the pensions industry.

First, the so called pension freedoms. I’m not sure his opposite numbers in the DWP knew it was coming. Definitely his initiative- and with unforeseen (or seen and discarded) consequences. By copying the Australian model, we are in danger of opening up the nation to ‘double dippers’ as Australia calls them. People that take their cash, miss-use it, or miss-calculate and end up dependent on the State to survive.

And now a consultation document considering scrapping tax relief on pensions. Throughout my 38 years in the pension industry, alongside company contributions, the one thing that ‘sells’ pensions to youngsters is the tax relief. If pensions get treated the same way as ISA’s, then ‘goodbye pensions’. The industry becomes a savings industry, and over time (with unforeseen consequences and/or an uncaring Government), people will find that they didn’t save enough and can’t live on what’s there in retirement.

Short term treasury gains are in danger of sending the next generation into retirement poverty.

Instant Society

Yesterday was Pension Awareness Day. The BBC ran a pensions programme called Inside Out, looking at the pension cheats and the need to save. It even had a cameo performance from Steve Webb, chatting to pensioners on a bus.

Joan is 93. In the programme she comments on the cultural shift towards spending now.

'Nowadays, young people don't know how to save - because they've never had to save. It's a throwaway society. They've never had to make do and mend like we had to.'

There's something in that. In our instant, 40,000 googles-a-second society, everything is instant. Saving isn't.

Pensions Poverty

I welcome the budget changes to pensions. I really do. But the truth is, it’s benefits for the privileged offered by the privileged (to misquote Ed Milliband). Here’s a Facebook message that was posted today by Monika, a lady in my church:

Dear George Osborne,

I'm glad that future pensioners will be able to draw down their annuities and that people with the money to spare can put more of it into ISA's and that, probably those same pensioners can save via a Pensioner's Bond.

But please explain where those pensioners with little, or no, spare cash will be better off.

Personally, when I was a single working mother, I saved what I could in an annuity, only to find out when I retired, that, as it did not amount to £23,000 I was not allowed to withdraw it and had to receive an annuity of, wait for it, £12 a year (!). Even if I live to 100+ I'll never be able to draw out what I put in and now, because I've already retired, it's still locked away.

It seems to me that many pensioners will still not be any better off, despite the media's proclamations, so don't be surprised if you don't get my vote in the next general Election.

Her comments are pretty typical of the real issues we face. Pensions poverty is real.

And what’s worse, according to the Institute of Economic Affairs, we can’t do much about it either. They advise that promises made by successive governments have not been honoured from the existing tax base. So we can’t afford to pay what we’ve promised to pay, and according to IEA’s Philip Booth, ‘it is quite possible that we will not find our way through without serious social breakdown’.

That’s the sobering message behind the mild euphoria in the pensions industry provoked by yesterday’s budget announcements.

Pensions Week (RIP)

The final print edition of Pensions Week. Some fine words about the benefits of an online edition with a new title (Pensions Expert). But surely this is an admission of poor circulation, high print costs and a saturated market dominated by Professional Pensions?

ADDENDUM 18/12: Tweet from Pensions Week- they are still doing a print edition as 'Pensions Expert' so I don't have to search them out online. Pleased to hear it! Keep up the competition with Professional Pensions you guys!

Not so much a dogs life.....

Just had to check my calendar. No, it’s not April 1^st. So the headline in Pensions Age is genuine- the police are paying pensions to dogs!

It’s kind of funny, but sad at the same time. Up to £1,500 per dog, it’s actually a subsidy for the pet owners who take the dogs in at the end of the dogs police career.

At the risk of upsetting pet owners everywhere (and I was one until a couple of years ago- Wesley, our wonderful Chocolate Labrador), I can’t see how we can justify pensions for pets. I work in India alongside charity workers who get less than that a year. And amongst the poorest of the Dalit community who live on next to nothing.

Punter Southall are quoted in the article, saying ‘retired Nottinghamshire police dogs will be better provided for by their employers than many in our society’. It’s a strange world.

The Corporate Version of Caring for Your Parents

As you get older and your parents get frail, there comes a point when you have to decide how to care for them. If it’s a decision to put them in a care home, the costs have to be found. Often that will be through selling their home. And remember, it’s often your childhood home too. Sad that their care requires the sale of something with such precious memories.

When Defined Benefit plans were ‘invented’, they were affordable. A combination of longevity, market changes and strict accounting practices means that this is no longer the case. So what to do? The promises have been made. You need to care for those where a pension has been promised. So sometimes, you have to sell what is precious to you.

That’s what has happened this week with the Royal Geographical Society. In order to fund the pension promises, they are selling some of their precious artwork. Paintings that have been in their collection for over a century.

Sad that promises made require the sale of something so precious and irreplaceable. Witness the corporate equivalent of selling the parental home. But the ongoing care of the elderly has to be more important than even the most beautiful of paintings. Or houses for that matter. Or businesses too?.....

What is a Pension?

First written 31 May 2012

What is a pension?

The dictionary says it’s ‘a regular payment made during a person’s retirement from an investment fund to which that person or their employer has contributed during their working life’.

You could say it’s a payment later in life for work done today. Maybe a promise given for work completed. Or simply financial security. All these and more, I’m sure.

What it isn’t is a promise to continue the promise into the future at the same rate as in the past. Times are hard. Companies have cut back on pensions. Government and local authorities have to do the same. So when council workers and doctors go on strike (or threaten to) on the basis of a reduction to pension, it’s the wrong argument to pick. They still have protected pensions to this point in time and the changes in the future are still far more generous than the average private sector pension plan.

My friend in India has a pension plan. It’s called the goodwill of his children to look after him. We really don’t know how lucky we are.